Turkeys voting for Christmas

January 4, 2010 -- (Cross-cultural note for us Americans: in the UK, the traditional Christmas dinner is turkey.) A fascinating article by BBC contributor David Runciman entitled Why do people often vote against their own interests? reviews writings by Drew Westen and Thomas Frank about the psychology of many American voters:

...it is striking that the people who most dislike the whole idea of healthcare reform - the ones who think it is socialist, godless, a step on the road to a police state - are often the ones it seems designed to help.

In Texas, where barely two-thirds of the population have full health insurance and over a fifth of all children have no cover at all, opposition to the legislation is currently running at 87%.

...Why are so many American voters enraged by attempts to change a horribly inefficient system that leaves them with premiums they often cannot afford?

Why are they manning the barricades to defend insurance companies that routinely deny claims and cancel policies?

The answer does not increase my respect for the decision-making processes of American voters. Westen's explanation is paraphrased:
...stories always trump statistics, which means the politician with the best stories is going to win: "One of the fallacies that politicians often have on the Left is that things are obvious, when they are not obvious.

"Obama's administration made a tremendous mistake by not immediately branding the economic collapse that we had just had as the Republicans' Depression, caused by the Bush administration's ideology of unregulated greed. The result is that now people blame him."

Paraphrasing Frank, the article observes:

...voters' preference for emotional engagement over reasonable argument has allowed the Republican Party to blind them to their own real interests.

The Republicans have learnt how to stoke up resentment against the patronising liberal elite, all those do-gooders who assume they know what poor people ought to be thinking.

Right-wing politics has become a vehicle for channelling this popular anger against intellectual snobs. The result is that many of America's poorest citizens have a deep emotional attachment to a party that serves the interests of its richest.

The article is part of a series entitled Turkeys voting for Christmas... How apt.

Table of Contents